The long-standing but far-fetched idea of Canada becoming the 51st U.S. state resurfaced during a recent meeting between former President Donald Trump and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney. Their discussion at the White House on May 6 blended diplomatic formalities with sharp exchanges, as Trump once again floated his controversial vision of absorbing Canada—an idea Carney firmly rejected.
Trump, known for his bold and often contentious proposals, entered the meeting with his usual confidence, suggesting that “everybody” would be interested in such a merger. He framed the potential union as a “wonderful marriage” between the two nations. However, Carney, Canada’s newly elected leader, was quick to shut down the notion. While acknowledging Trump as a “transformational president,” he made it clear that Canada’s sovereignty was non-negotiable.
Drawing on his background in economics and real estate, Carney emphasized that some things transcend financial or political transactions. “There are places that exist beyond marketplace values,” he stated, reinforcing his stance that Canada “is not for sale. Won’t be for sale, ever.” He further asserted Canada’s independence by referencing its historical ties to global institutions, subtly reminding Trump that the country answers to no foreign power.
Unfazed, Trump responded with his trademark optimism, quipping, “Never say never,” a phrase famously used by Canadian pop star Justin Bieber. He hinted at his history of achieving so-called impossible deals, leaving the door open for future discussions. But Carney’s resolve remained unshaken, signaling that Canada’s identity as a self-governing nation was not up for debate.
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney claps back hard at Trump’s idea about Canada becoming the 51st state.
Trump: "As a real estate developer, when you get rid of that artificial line, when you look at that beautiful formation together, I said, ‘that’s the way it was meant to… pic.twitter.com/oPqBuhLACc
— Ed Krassenstein (@EdKrassen) May 6, 2025
Body language experts noted the tension beneath the diplomatic smiles. Analyst Beth Dawson observed that while Carney maintained a composed demeanor, subtle signs of unease were visible, particularly in his cautious physical interactions with Trump. The exchange highlighted the delicate balance between diplomatic courtesy and national pride.
The meeting ultimately underscored a recurring theme in U.S.-Canada relations: periodic but unserious chatter about annexation, often fueled by Trump’s penchant for dramatic proposals. For now, Carney’s message was clear—Canada stands firm in its sovereignty, and no amount of political theater will change that.
